First Light × Go Global Agency
Meta Ads review
November 18, 2026
Team review. Click Add comment (bottom right), then click anywhere on the page to leave a note. No login needed.
Elk vs Wagyu · Meta conversion campaigns · Nov 2024 to Oct 2026

Wagyu carries the account. Elk is the cheaper reach.

Two years of Meta conversion campaigns, split by product. Year 1 is Nov 2024 to Oct 2025, Year 2 is Nov 2025 to Oct 2026. Combined Elk and Wagyu ad revenue grew from $699K to $1.22M.

First Light elk rack on a cutting board
Elk · Year 2
$406K
in ad revenue, up 78% year over year
2,627Purchases
3.37ROAS
$29912-month LTV
First Light wagyu steaks on a board and grill pan
Wagyu · Year 2
$813K
in ad revenue, up 73% year over year
4,180Purchases
4.24ROAS
$44112-month LTV
Year over year

What changed in 12 months

Wagyu is the bigger line and held its efficiency as spend grew. Elk grew faster and gave up more efficiency along the way.

Elk

Spend more than doubled

MetricYear 1Year 2Change
Spend$57.1K$120.2K+110%
Purchases1,4872,627+77%
Revenue$228K$406K+78%
ROAS4.003.37−16%
Cost / purchase$38$46+19%
Avg order$154$154flat
CPM$12.99$12.63−3%
Click → purchase3.1%2.4%−24%

Wagyu

Spend grew 79% and ROAS barely moved

MetricYear 1Year 2Change
Spend$107.3K$191.7K+79%
Purchases2,5064,180+67%
Revenue$470K$813K+73%
ROAS4.384.24−3%
Cost / purchase$43$46+7%
Avg order$188$194+4%
CPM$19.16$19.85+4%
Click → purchase4.7%3.4%−28%

Share of Elk + Wagyu spend

Year 1
Elk 35%
Wagyu 65%
Year 2
Elk 39%
Wagyu 61%
Month by month

Two years on one line

Switch between views. ROAS and cost per purchase are hidden in months where a meat spent under $500, since a handful of orders would distort them.

ElkWagyu
Shaded area = Year 2. Nov 2026 covers the 1st to the 17th only.
Customer lifetime value

What a first-time buyer is worth

From First Light's store data (Metorik), customers from every channel. Grouped by the meat in their first order.

Elk · 12-month LTV
$299
First order $173, then 19% buy again
Wagyu · 12-month LTV
$441
+47% vs Elk. First order $199, then 30% buy again

12-month value per ad dollar

12-month LTV ÷ Year 2 Meta cost per purchase ($46 for both)

Elk
6.5x
Wagyu
9.6x

How LTV builds after the first order

Average revenue per customer, customers who first bought Nov 2024 to Oct 2025

ElkWagyu

LTV by customer age

Up to 12 months: 1,863 Elk and 3,524 Wagyu customers. 24 months: customers who first bought Nov 2023 to Oct 2024. Last two rows: everyone who first bought Nov 2024 to Oct 2026 with only Elk or only Wagyu in that first order.

MonthsElkWagyuGap
First order$173$199+15%
3 months$230$301+31%
6 months$257$354+38%
12 months$299$441+47%
24 months$419$713+70%
Bought again19%30%+11 pts
Active subscriptions282097.5x
Takeaways

What the numbers say

01

A Wagyu customer is worth far more

First-time Wagyu buyers spend $441 in their first year vs $299 for Elk (+47%). By 24 months the gap is $713 vs $419 (+70%).

02

The gap comes from repeat buying

First orders are close ($199 vs $173). After that, 30% of Wagyu buyers come back vs 19% of Elk buyers, and Wagyu buyers hold 209 active subscriptions vs 28.

03

Same ad cost, very different payback

Both meats cost about $46 per purchase on Meta in Year 2. A new Wagyu buyer returns about 9.6x that in a year, an Elk buyer about 6.5x.

04

Elk's cheaper reach doesn't close the gap

Elk's CPM is 36% lower ($12.63 vs $19.85), but each Elk customer is worth 32% less in year one, and Wagyu turns more clicks into orders (3.4% vs 2.4%).

05

Wagyu scaled without losing much

Wagyu took 61% of Year 2 spend and brought in 67% of the revenue ($813K). Spend grew 79% while ROAS only slipped from 4.38 to 4.24.

06

Elk grew faster and less steadily

Elk spend more than doubled and ROAS fell from 4.00 to 3.37. It sat at 1.9 to 2.7 from March to August 2026 before recovering to 3.4 to 7.1 since September.

The short version

Wagyu wins on the first sale and wins bigger over time. Elk is cheaper reach, but every Elk buyer is worth about $140 less in year one.

Elk + Wagyu conversion campaigns returned $1.22M on $312K in Year 2, up from $699K on $164K. The customer value data says Wagyu deserves the larger share of that budget.

Notes on the data
  • Source: Meta Ads through Supermetrics, both First Light ad accounts ("First Light USA - Go Global" and the older "First Light Farms USA", now closed). Pulled November 18, 2026.
  • Only Sales-objective (conversion) campaigns are included. Awareness and traffic campaigns are left out.
  • Dog food and dog treat ads are removed ($19.8K over the two years). An ad counts as Elk when its name mentions Elk, or its ad set or campaign does and the ad itself doesn't name Wagyu. Every other ad counts as Wagyu.
  • That means the Wagyu number also holds small amounts of venison ($1.4K), organ supplements ($2.5K), holiday boxes and catalog ads. Catalog ads show whichever product Meta picks, so a share of them may have shown Elk.
  • Purchases and revenue are what the Meta pixel credits to the ads (Meta's default attribution), not Shopify sales.
  • Year 1 = Nov 1, 2024 to Oct 31, 2025. Year 2 = Nov 1, 2025 to Oct 31, 2026. Nov 1 to 17, 2026 appears in the chart only.
  • ROAS = pixel revenue ÷ spend. Click → purchase = purchases ÷ link clicks. Amounts in USD.
  • LTV comes from First Light's WooCommerce store through Metorik, pulled November 18, 2026. It is revenue per customer before product costs, and covers customers from every channel, not only Meta.
  • LTV curves use Metorik's "first category purchased" (Elk vs Wagyu Beef). Customers whose first purchase was a gift box or subscription are not in either curve.
  • LTV per ad dollar divides 12-month LTV by Meta's cost per purchase, which also counts repeat buyers. The true cost of a new customer is higher, so read 6.5x and 9.6x as a comparison, not exact payback.